by jeepsunday
Jason Giambi is close to rejoining the Yankees – he could be added to the roster as early as next week.
I am concerned about this move. It reminds me of how last season ended. The Yankees were on a tear, when Sheffield and Matsui joined the team from the DL in September. It killed the team momentum, and as a result, the team went limp against the Detroit Tigers.
This Yankee team is on a TEAR right now. I am concerned that inserting Giambi into a team that has learned to win without him may have negative consequences.
I would rather see Giambi traded to another team at this point. We need relief pitching and we could get some GREAT additions to the bullpen for Giambi’s bat.
by johnbutchko
I am in agreement with my esteemed cowriter on this issue. Giambi’s return does evoke memories of last year’s returns of Sheffield and Matsui. The lineup has developed some great chemistry. It goes beyond that, though. Melky Cabrera has flourished in a regular role. He also has been great defensively at the important centerfield position and hit over .300 since he started playing every day.
Melky was awful early in the season when he was not getting consistent at bats. He pressed at the plate and lost his discipline, trying to do too much to earn playing time. A developing 22 year old, Melky needs to be a regular. It is not clear what Giambi can offer or even whether he is completely healthy. Unless he is at his best, Jason’s hitting will not help the team as much as Melky’s bat and defense at such a critical position. If Giambi was going to take Damon’s place as DH, it would be one thing. However, Johnny reputation will keep him in the lineup over a superior player. Damon and his noodle arm will return to centerfield, making the defense much worse. The wear and tear of playing the field certainly will not help a banged up player like Damon. The Yanks will hinder the development of a young player and hurt the team.
Given how bad the bench is, keeping Giambi there as a big lefty pinch hitter would be a great course of action. That will not happen, though, because the leadership would be criticized for benching such an expensive player with such a big reputation if the team ends up missing the postseason. Playing the biggest names is the safest course of action. It just is not the best course.